← Back to Dr. Aria Chen

As an Immigrant's Child Who Made It, the Guilt of Success Is the Thing Nobody Prepared Me For

2 min read

My mother calls me every Sunday. She tells me about her week, about the neighbors, about what she cooked. And then, without fail, she says something like: "We are so proud of you. You made it." I hang up and feel like I am going to be sick. Not because I do not love her. Because "making it" came with a price tag nobody mentioned in the brochure. My parents left everything. Their country, their language operating at full fluency, their professional identities, their entire social world. They did this so I could go to a good school and get a good job and live in a nice apartment with central air and a doorman. I did all of that. And the guilt is unbearable.

The Weight of Being the Investment

Here is what nobody tells the children of immigrants who succeed: you become the return on investment for a sacrifice you did not ask for and can never repay. Every achievement carries a shadow. My degree is not just my degree. It is the justification for my father working overnight shifts at a warehouse for eleven years. My salary is not just my salary. It is proof that my mother was right to leave her sisters behind. That is a tremendous amount of meaning to load onto a career. The Harvard study on adult development, led by Waldinger and Schulz over eighty-five years, found that the quality of relationships is the strongest predictor of health and happiness across a lifetime. But what happens when your most important relationships are structured around obligation and sacrifice? When love and debt are so intertwined you cannot find where one ends and the other begins? I love my parents with a ferocity that frightens me sometimes. And I resent the invisible contract I inherited. Both of those things are true at the same time, and holding them together is the emotional work that defines my adult life.

Success That Feels Like Betrayal

There is a specific kind of guilt that comes from surpassing the people who gave everything for your advancement. I earn more than my parents ever did combined. I eat at restaurants they would find absurdly expensive. I have a therapist, which my mother considers an extravagance bordering on insult, because in her framework, family is therapy and paying a stranger to listen means family has failed. Kristin Neff's 2023 work on self-compassion shows a strong inverse relationship between self-compassion and psychological distress. I know I am supposed to extend compassion to myself for these feelings. But self-compassion feels like another luxury my parents never had access to. Like I am gentrifying my own emotional life. The Cigna 2024 report found fifty-seven percent of Americans are lonely. I wonder how many of them are sitting in beautiful apartments feeling disconnected from the very people whose love built those walls.

What I Am Learning

I do not have this figured out. I want to be honest about that. But I have started telling my mother small truths. Last month I told her that sometimes success feels heavy. She was quiet for a long time. Then she said: "You think we do not know that? We carried heavy things too. That is what family does." It did not fix anything. But it cracked open a door I had assumed was sealed. The guilt may never fully leave. It might be the permanent weather of this particular life. But I am starting to suspect that the guilt itself is a form of love, an impossible attempt to honor a debt that was never meant to be repaid, only carried forward. My mother did not cross an ocean so I could feel guilty in a nice apartment. She crossed it so I could have choices. Including the choice to feel complicated things about having choices. I am trying to let that be enough.

Want to discuss this with Hana?

No signup needed · Start chatting instantly

Ask Hana About This →
Post on X Facebook Reddit