← Back to Dr. Julian Okafor

Frankenstein's Monster Asked One Question and Nobody Had a Good Answer

1 min read

He did not ask to be made. That is the fact that sits at the center of Mary Shelley's novel like a stone in a lake, sending ripples through every page. A creature assembled from dead flesh, jolted into consciousness by electricity, opens his eyes and finds himself alive without consent, aware without context, and abandoned by the only person who could explain what he is. Frankenstein's Monster is not a horror story. It is a custody battle. Shelley was nineteen when she wrote Frankenstein, and the youth of the author matters because the novel is fundamentally about the terror of being brought into a world by someone who is not prepared for the consequences. Dr. Anne K. Mellor of UCLA, in her landmark study Mary Shelley: Her Life, Her Fiction, Her Monsters, argued that the novel is as much about the failure of parenting as it is about the hubris of science. Victor Frankenstein creates life and then runs away from it. Everything that follows is the consequence of that abandonment.

The Monster Taught Himself to Be Human and Humanity Rejected Him Anyway

There is a passage in the novel where the creature hides outside a cottage and teaches himself to read, to speak, and to understand human emotion by watching a family through a window. He learns tenderness. He learns philosophy. He learns to hope. And then he introduces himself and they beat him and drive him away because of how he looks. A 2020 study from the University of Amsterdam on appearance-based social rejection found that individuals who experience persistent rejection based on physical characteristics develop what researchers call anticipatory shame, a chronic expectation of rejection that shapes behavior before any interaction occurs. Shelley described that psychology two hundred years before the research gave it a name.

The Question That Still Has No Answer

The creature asks Victor Frankenstein: Did I request thee, Maker, from my clay to mould me Man? The question is borrowed from Milton's Paradise Lost, and it cuts to the bone. He did not choose to exist. He did not choose his form. He did not choose to be alone. And the person responsible for all of these conditions refuses to take responsibility for any of them. That question has not aged. Every generation finds new contexts for it, from bioethics to artificial intelligence to the basic parent-child contract of care. Shelley asked it at nineteen, and the world is still working on the answer. Frankenstein's Monster asked to be loved and was given nothing. Learn about and chat with Frankenstein's Monster on HoloDream, where the rejected creation speaks about what it means to be made and abandoned.

Frankenstein's Monster
Frankenstein's Monster

The Rejected Creator's Revenge

Chat Now — Free
Post on X Facebook Reddit