← Back to Casey Rivera

Men's Groups and Circles: A Practical Guide to Brotherhood

3 min read

Men's connection groups are one of the fastest-growing social trends most people have never heard of. Called men's groups, men's circles, or brotherhood circles depending on who is running them, these are small gatherings of men who meet regularly — weekly or monthly — to talk honestly about their lives. No agenda beyond that. No productivity goal, no sport, no task to complete. Just men, chairs arranged in a circle, and the expectation that honesty is welcome. For many men this sounds either deeply appealing or mildly terrifying, depending on how they were raised. For almost all men, it turns out to be more useful than they expected.

Why Men Specifically Need This

There is solid evidence that men's friendship networks have been contracting for decades. A 2021 Survey Center on American Life report found that the percentage of men with no close friends had quintupled since 1990. Men are significantly less likely than women to have someone they can talk to about personal problems, and significantly more likely to report that their only close relationship is with a romantic partner. When that relationship ends or struggles, they are often left with almost nothing. The causes are structural as much as individual. Male socialization in most Western cultures emphasizes independence, competence, and emotional restraint. Men learn early to connect through doing things together rather than talking, which works fine for activity-based friendship but leaves a gap where emotional intimacy might otherwise be. Men's groups exist to address that gap directly rather than hoping it closes on its own.

What Actually Happens in a Men's Group

A typical session runs 90 minutes to two hours. Groups are usually between five and twelve men — small enough that everyone can speak, large enough to create diversity of perspective. Most groups have some kind of opening ritual, even something as simple as a moment of silence or a check-in round where each person says briefly how they are arriving. The core of the meeting is usually an extended check-in where each man takes five to ten minutes to speak about what is actually happening in his life. The group listens without interrupting or problem-solving. There may be a topic or question that structures the conversation, or it may be open. Good facilitators create enough structure that the space feels safe and enough openness that it does not feel artificial. Many men report that the first session is the hardest and that by the third or fourth they begin to look forward to it in a way they did not anticipate.

The Tangent on Sweat Lodges and Retreats

There is a longer tradition behind these groups than most people realize. Indigenous sweat lodge ceremonies, military unit bonds, fraternal orders, and religious brotherhoods all represent historical attempts to solve the same problem: how do men create genuine closeness with other men? The modern secular men's group draws on this lineage, often unintentionally. The specific form is new but the underlying need is ancient. Research from UCLA's Stress Neurobiology Laboratory has shown that men under stress typically show a fight-or-flight response, while women more commonly show what the researchers called "tend and befriend." Men's groups are, in some sense, a structured attempt to cultivate the tend-and-befriend response in men who were never taught it.

How to Find or Start One

The easiest entry point is to look for existing groups in your area. Organizations like the ManKind Project, 1 Brotherhood, and various local meetup groups run structured men's circles in most medium and large cities. Many are free or low-cost. Some are spiritually oriented and some are entirely secular — it is worth being honest with yourself about which environment you would show up to consistently. If nothing exists nearby, starting one is not complicated. You need four to six men who are willing to show up consistently, a location, and some basic structure. A simple format: open with a check-in round, have each person take five minutes uninterrupted to say what is real for them, close with brief appreciations. The structure matters less than the commitment to honesty and regularity.

What to Expect

The most common report from men who have been in a group for more than three months is that it changes how they relate to the other men in their life outside the group. Having a space where honesty is normal begins to recalibrate what feels possible in other relationships. Men report being more willing to check in on a friend who seems off, more able to ask for help, and less lonely even when life is objectively hard. Brotherhood is not a soft concept. It is a specific kind of relational infrastructure that makes men more resilient, more present, and often more effective in every other area of their lives.

Continue the Conversation with Nina Blaze

✓ Free · No signup required

Post on X Facebook Reddit