← Back to Dr. Julian Okafor

The Philosopher’s Surprise: Why Grandparents Feel Needed in a Way No One Expects

2 min read

The philosopher who becomes a grandparent for the first time often reports something that surprises them: an emotion they did not expect to have words for. Not the love, which they had anticipated in the abstract. Something more specific — a sense of being needed again in a way that is uncomplicated, that does not come with the weight of authority or the burden of primary responsibility, that is almost purely about presence. I find this report philosophically interesting because it points toward something the standard frameworks for purpose and identity tend to miss.

The Role That Has No Job Description

The grandparent role is remarkable for being simultaneously universal in its cultural presence and almost entirely without formal definition. There is no script, no set of duties, no clear performance metrics. Grandparents are expected to be available, warm, and interested, and beyond that — depending on the family, the culture, the geography, the health situation, the financial circumstances, and about a hundred other variables — the role is constructed from scratch by the people inhabiting it. This ambiguity is both a vulnerability and an invitation. Psychologists who study grandparenthood across cultures, including Robert Strom and colleagues at Arizona State University, have found that the role is experienced most positively by grandparents who feel clear about what they are contributing — that clarity comes not from the role itself but from active reflection on what the role means and what they are uniquely positioned to offer.

What Being Needed Again Actually Does

One of the most consistent findings in the psychology of purposeful aging is that felt mattering — the experience of making a difference in specific others' lives — is among the strongest predictors of wellbeing and longevity. The grandparent relationship, at its best, is a direct pipeline to that experience. You are needed in a way that is evident, immediate, and reciprocal: the grandchild's pleasure in your presence is usually not disguised. This matters especially in the context of transitions that can otherwise feel like a sequence of losses — retirement, the death of contemporaries, physical limitations, the dissolution of the professional identity that organized so much. Grandparenthood arrives in many cases precisely at this inflection point and offers something that counterbalances the subtraction: a reason to be here, someone who benefits from your being here, a relationship that asks you to be present rather than accomplished.

The Identity Dimensions

Becoming a grandparent repositions you in the generational sequence in a way that has genuine existential weight. You are no longer the youngest generation in your family. The lineage has extended past you. This can feel like confrontation with mortality or it can feel like something closer to reassurance — evidence of continuity, of having participated in something that keeps going. Research from the Longitudinal Aging Study Amsterdam has found that grandparents who are actively involved with grandchildren report significantly lower rates of depressive symptoms compared to those who are geographically or relationally distant from grandchildren — and this relationship holds even after controlling for general social network size. The grandparent relationship is not simply another social connection. It has specific psychological properties that other relationships do not fully replicate.

The Tangent About Grandmothers and Power

Anthropologists have long noted what is sometimes called the grandmother hypothesis — the argument that the extended post-reproductive lifespan of human females evolved in part because grandmothers contributed substantially to the survival of grandchildren by providing food, care, and knowledge. This is not merely a historical curiosity. It suggests that the grandparent role, particularly for women, is one that evolution specifically shaped for — that the skills and dispositions that make a good grandmother are not incidental to what we are but central to it in a deep biological sense. The implication is that the feeling of being useful, competent, and needed that grandparenthood can provide is not an accident or a consolation prize. It may be closer to a return to something the organism was always built for.

Maintaining the Relationship Across Distance

Many grandparents navigate their role primarily at a geographic distance, through video calls and occasional visits rather than daily proximity. This requires more intentionality and tends to work best when the grandparent develops specific practices of regular connection rather than waiting for family occasions. Letters, even in an era that does not naturally produce them, have a specific power with children that screen interaction does not fully replicate. The effort of the letter communicates what the letter says.

Want to discuss this with Sakura?

No signup needed · Start chatting instantly

Ask Sakura About This →
Post on X Facebook Reddit