What Should I Do When I Feel Like a Fraud? The Imposter Syndrome Playbook.
When you feel like a fraud, the first move is to recognize that the feeling itself is evidence you are engaged with something meaningful and probably performing at or above competence. Imposter syndrome is not a character defect but a common cognitive pattern where your internal assessment of your ability cannot keep up with your actual performance and responsibilities. The experience is real, but the conclusion it draws is usually wrong. Your job is not to eliminate the feeling, because highly accomplished people often carry it throughout their careers. Your job is to stop letting it drive your decisions and to build routines that provide external reality checks when your internal ones are broken. Dr. Valerie Young, the author of The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women and one of the foremost researchers on imposter syndrome, has identified five common imposter types: the Perfectionist, the Expert, the Soloist, the Natural Genius, and the Superhuman. Each has a different internal rule that gets triggered. Research published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine in 2020, synthesizing 62 studies, found that imposter syndrome affects approximately 70 percent of people at some point in their careers and is particularly common among high-achievers, first-generation professionals, and members of groups underrepresented in their field. You are in extraordinary company. And you can learn to work with the feeling rather than be run by it. Here is how.
Which Imposter Type Are You?
Dr. Young's framework is useful because the intervention differs by type. The Perfectionist feels like a fraud if the work is not flawless, so the fix is to define good enough deliberately in advance. The Expert feels like a fraud if they do not know everything, so the fix is to name what you know and accept that expertise is domain-specific. The Soloist feels like a fraud if they ask for help, so the fix is to reframe help-seeking as collaboration. The Natural Genius feels like a fraud if something takes effort, so the fix is to embrace learning curves as normal. The Superhuman feels like a fraud if they cannot do everything, so the fix is to practice triage. Knowing your type lets you intervene at the right lever.
What Is the Internal Rule You Are Breaking?
Every imposter episode has an unspoken rule behind it. "Real professionals do not make mistakes." "People like me do not belong in rooms like this." "If I ask a question I will expose myself as incompetent." These rules were often learned early and have not been updated as you have grown. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, which has the strongest evidence base of any psychotherapy for anxiety, encourages naming the rule explicitly so you can examine it. Write down the specific rule your mind is enforcing right now. Ask yourself: would I apply this rule to someone I respect who is in a similar role? The answer is almost always no.
What Is the Evidence For and Against?
Make two columns. In one, list the actual evidence that you are capable of doing this thing. The job you were hired for. The feedback you have received. The projects you have completed. In the other, list the evidence that you are a fraud. Usually the second column contains feelings rather than facts. Dr. Pauline Clance, who co-introduced the concept of imposter phenomenon in 1978, developed an assessment scale still widely used today, and her research emphasized that people with imposter syndrome systematically discount positive feedback and over-weight negative feedback. You are probably doing this right now. Make the bias visible on the page.
Who Can Reality-Check You?
Identify two or three trusted people who know your work and who will tell you the truth. Not cheerleaders, not critics, but honest mirrors. A mentor, a peer in your field, a former manager, a long-time friend. When you are in the fog of imposter syndrome, you cannot trust your own self-assessment, so you need external calibration. Dr. Robert Waldinger, director of the Harvard Study of Adult Development, has shown across 85 years of longitudinal data that high-quality relationships are among the strongest predictors of wellbeing. Reality-check relationships are a specific category worth investing in.
How Do You Respond in the Moment?
When imposter syndrome spikes, try a two-sentence intervention: "I notice I am having the thought that I am a fraud. This thought is a known cognitive pattern called imposter syndrome, and it is not evidence of anything except that I care about doing well." Then return your attention to the actual task. This is a cognitive defusion technique from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, which has meta-analytic support for reducing the impact of unhelpful thoughts without needing to argue with them or eliminate them. The goal is not to stop having the thought. The goal is to stop letting the thought stop you.
What Should You Not Do?
Do not wait to feel confident before acting. Confidence almost always follows competence, not the other way around. People who wait to feel ready often never act, and the feeling of readiness rarely arrives on schedule. Do not compare your insides to other people's outsides. Everyone around you who looks effortlessly competent is running their own internal monologue, and research consistently shows that the most accomplished people are often the most uncertain. Do not mistake impostor feelings for intuition. They are emotional reactions, not information about reality.
What About the Structural Component?
Imposter syndrome is not purely internal. If you are from a group underrepresented in your field, the environment itself may be sending signals that you do not belong. A 2021 paper published in Harvard Business Review by Ruchika Tulshyan and Jodi-Ann Burey argued that imposter syndrome has been over-individualized and that systemic bias, not personal insecurity, is often the real driver. This does not mean the feeling is invalid. It means the cure is not only personal work but also finding environments and mentors that actively make room for you.
When Should You Seek Professional Help?
If imposter syndrome is causing chronic anxiety, interfering with sleep, driving perfectionism that damages your health or relationships, or contributing to depression, please talk to a therapist. CBT, ACT, and schema-focused therapy all have good track records for this pattern. You do not have to suffer in silence because the suffering seems like part of being accomplished. You are probably better at what you do than you think. Do the work anyway, and let competence slowly catch up to your doubt.
Want to discuss this with Dr. Amara?
No signup needed · Start chatting instantly
Ask Dr. Amara About This →