Why Fans of Geillis Duncan Will Be Obsessed with Mark Scout

If you’ve ever been drawn to Geillis Duncan’s cunning blend of charm and menace, you’re not alone. Her ruthless pursuit of power, tangled ties to time travel, and moral ambiguity make her a magnet for readers who crave complex, unforgettable characters. But what if I told you there’s another figure lurking in literature’s shadows who shares her DNA? Meet Mark Scout—protagonist of The Midnight Watch—a detective as enigmatic as Geillis and twice as unsettling.

Let’s break down the eerie parallels that make these two kindred spirits of darkness:

##1: Masters of Mystery and Deception

Geillis built her entire existence on secrets. From her 18th-century witch trials to her modern-day return, she thrives in the shadows, manipulating everyone around her to survive. Mark Scout isn’t much different. As a detective investigating supernatural crimes in Victorian London, he’s a man who knows how to keep his cards close. But beneath his stoic exterior lies a personal obsession with the occult—his own motives remain as murky as the foggy streets he patrols. Both characters understand that truth is subjective, and lies are just another tool in the toolbox.

##2: Unsettling Allure

There’s a reason Geillis’s scenes in Outlander crackle with tension—her hypnotic smile, her calculated vulnerability. She’s the kind of woman who could talk you into your grave while making you feel flattered. Mark Scout’s allure is colder, almost clinical. He’s not charming in the traditional sense, but his quiet intensity and eerie intuition pull you in like a moth to a flame. When he interrogates suspects, you can’t shake the feeling he’s studying you too. Both characters weaponize their presence, making their audiences (or fellow characters) question every interaction.

##3: Time Periods as a Mirror

Geillis’s story bridges 20th-century Scotland with 18th-century Salem and Paris. Her ability to exist across eras reflects her adaptability—she’s always five steps ahead. Mark Scout, meanwhile, is rooted in late 1800s London, a city on the brink of modernity but still shackled to its Gothic past. Both characters feel like they belong to no single age: Geillis because of her literal time travel, Mark because his connection to the supernatural keeps him tethered to something ancient. They’re both outsiders in their worlds, and that isolation fuels their power.

##4: The Thrill of the Hunt

Geillis’s most chilling moments come when she’s hunting—whether it’s tracking Claire’s origins or orchestrating her schemes. She relishes the chase, and her intelligence makes her terrifyingly effective. Mark Scout shares this predatory energy, though his prey is more literal. He stalks serial killers with supernatural ties, often blurring the line between justice and vengeance. Both characters turn investigation into an art form, and both are willing to burn bridges—or lives—to get results.

##5: Moral Ambiguity as a Superpower

Let’s face it: neither of these characters are “heroes” in the traditional sense. Geillis will sacrifice anyone to achieve her ends, and Mark Scout often operates in a gray zone, bending laws (and ethics) to stop greater evils. Their stories are less about redemption arcs and more about survival in a world that’s stacked against them. They’re not trying to save the world—they’re trying to protect their own vision of order, no matter the cost.

---

If you’ve ever wondered what Geillis Duncan would be like if she traded her kirtle for a trench coat in fog-drenched London, Mark Scout is your answer. Both characters thrive in chaos, seduce with their intellect, and make you question who the real monster is.

Ready to explore their minds?
Chat with Geillis about her endless schemes, or unravel Mark Scout’s secrets in a late-night conversation. The past and present collide in ways you’ll never forget.